21 November 2026, 06:49
330 Projects and 17.3 Billion: How the Action Plan for the Odessa Development Strategy Is Structured
Ця стаття також доступна українською
IMAGE: AI
The Odesa City Council has approved the Action Plan for the City’s Development Strategy for 2026–2027. Intent analyzed the document’s structure, the funding required for its implementation, and the effectiveness of the performance indicators outlined in it.
What Lies Behind the 330 Projects
So, the Odesa City Council has finally approved the Action Plan for the Odesa Development Strategy. The approved version includes 330 local development projects and initiatives. Is that a lot or a little? It’s clearly quite a few, considering that the current Strategy remains in effect until the end of 2027. On the other hand, the projects are assigned to various departments and implementing agencies, so work can proceed in parallel. Furthermore, the number 330 itself is a somewhat relative indicator of the scale of the work: the Plan includes not only large-scale infrastructure projects but also the development of strategic documents, research, procurement, and various organizational measures. The authors of the document themselves note that the projects vary in nature, scale, and level of detail.
As is well known, the Strategy comprises five strategic goals. The largest number of projects—103—falls under the strategic goal “Odesa—a city that develops and retains strong human capital.” These include education, healthcare, social services, youth policy, sports, support for veterans, and employment. Another 93 projects are included under the objective “Odesa—an institutionally resilient and cohesive city,” which specifically covers sectors such as culture, local self-government, spatial development, and transportation. Seventy-eight projects relate to a sustainable and safe urban environment. Significantly fewer projects fall under international cooperation (32) and economic development (24).
Based on this data, can we conclude, for example, that human capital is incomparably more important than the economy? It is probably not wise to draw such a conclusion. Let us emphasize once again that the projects vary greatly. For example, the restoration of historic buildings is difficult to compare with the meetings of the historical and toponymic commission. After reviewing the items in the document, another question arises: should meetings, gatherings, and conferences be included in the Action Plan as separate projects? I would say no. Such activities may be necessary stages in project implementation, but in and of themselves, they are more like working tools for municipal agencies. A strategic project should be aimed at a specific change or concrete result, while meetings are merely one of the ways to achieve it.
The projects in the Action Plan have various origins. The city council’s executive bodies analyzed existing municipal target and comprehensive programs, the Medium-Term Plan for Priority Public Investments, as well as proposals from the public. The document states that 61 proposals were received from the public, of which only 18 were included in the Plan. Thus, public initiatives constitute a negligible portion of the overall list.
We can note that the Action Plan includes 330 very diverse projects and activities. To understand the true significance of these initiatives, the sheer number alone is not enough. The Plan’s priorities are revealed much more clearly by how much funding is allocated to different project categories and where that money is expected to come from.
Where the Most Money Is Allocated in the Plan
According to the document, full implementation of the Action Plan will require 17.3 billion hryvnias. It is important to note that this is not funding that has already been allocated, but rather an estimated need. Nearly 60% of this amount is earmarked for 2027. The authors of the document explain this by noting that only preparatory work is planned for some of the projects in 2026.
Most of the necessary funds—62%—are planned to come from the budget of the Odesa City Territorial Community. Another 33% is expected to come from international technical assistance, investor funds, and grants. The remaining needs are to be covered by the state budget. Thus, more than one-third of the city’s Action Plan depends on potential external funding. The Plan itself explicitly attributes the need for such co-financing to the limited resources of the city budget amid the war.
The allocation of funds toward strategic goals differs significantly from the allocation based on the number of projects. The goal related to a sustainable and safe urban environment requires the largest amount of funding—just over 7 billion hryvnias. An institutionally resilient and cohesive city is projected to require 5.8 billion, while human capital development is projected to require 4.2 billion. Rounding out the list are, once again, economic development (176 million hryvnias) and international and intermunicipal cooperation—6.8 million.
These figures show that the number of projects within the strategic goals does not correlate directly with the planned funding. An analysis of the document indicates that the difference in funding for these goals stems from the nature of the planned activities. Specifically, the international component consists largely of organizational and communication efforts, whereas the security and infrastructure areas entail significant capital expenditures.
It is also interesting to note that a significant portion of the projects and measures do not require separate funding at all. These are primarily organizational, regulatory, and coordination activities that executive bodies are expected to carry out using existing resources. Thus, there are significant disparities in the funding of individual projects: ranging from zero to hundreds of millions of hryvnias. For example, the development of documentation and the restoration of historic buildings are estimated in the Plan at 317 million hryvnias: 67 million is to be provided by the city budget, and another 250 million is planned to be raised from other sources. Fortunately, the aforementioned meeting of the Historical and Toponymic Commission does not require separate funding.
For now, the amounts listed in the Plan should be viewed primarily as a financial model for implementing the Strategy, rather than as a list of already guaranteed expenditures. Much will depend on the capacity of the city budget amid the war and the ability to secure external funding.
Can the Results Be Measured?
Performance indicators are a weak point in the Action Plan. The document states that indicators must be specific, measurable, and achievable; they must allow for an assessment of the degree to which the set goal has been achieved and ensure the project can be monitored. In practice, this requirement is far from being met everywhere.
For some projects, the indicator essentially just repeats the name of the activity itself. For example, one project involves developing a management plan for the UNESCO World Heritage Site “Historic Center of Odesa” and a monitoring system. The performance indicator is “management plan developed.” In other words, the project consists of creating a document, and the very fact that the document was created serves as the indicator of its success.
An even more telling example is the previously mentioned holding of meetings of the Historical and Toponymic Commission. The project calls for meetings to be held in 2026–2027, and the indicator is defined as “one meeting held.” First, this is yet another instance where the name of the activity is repeated in the indicator. Second, holding a single meeting over two years is hardly a meaningful measure of effectiveness. A positive aspect of this indicator is that it is easy to measure. However, the problem runs a bit deeper: the indicator should capture a specific achievement that is useful for implementing the Strategy. Holding a meeting in and of itself is unlikely to bring the Strategy’s implementation any closer. However, adopting a decision at that meeting regarding a specific number of facilities could indeed be of strategic importance.
A similar pattern occurs regularly in the Action Plan. Indicators created using this model allow one to verify whether a planned action has been carried out, but they are much less effective at answering the question of whether that action produced the desired result.
The presence of a numerical value in an outcome indicator is supposed to guarantee its specificity and measurability—and, consequently, its quality. In practice, things are a bit more complicated. For example, one project aimed at supporting entrepreneurship specifies a numerical target: 2,300 people are to receive consultations. Formally, the indicator is set up correctly; however, the number of consultations alone says little about the outcome for implementing the Strategy. A more meaningful indicator could be, for example, the number or percentage of consultation participants who subsequently started their own businesses.
At the same time, the document contains significantly better examples. For the creation of a pedestrian space on Teatralna Square, the outcome is defined as an additional pedestrian zone covering 250 square meters. In the project to restore historic buildings, the outcome is defined as three restored sites. In both cases, the indicators allow for an assessment of the specific outcome of the work, rather than merely the fact that a certain procedure was carried out.
The document also includes interesting examples where indicators are designed to measure not only the work performed but also its impact. For example, according to the Plan, the introduction of a digital telemedicine consultation service is expected to reduce the burden on primary care by 10%. However, the monitoring and measurement mechanism itself may pose a challenge here.
The action plan calls for monitoring and reporting on the work performed based on performance indicators. If an indicator measures only the fact that an action was taken, then the resulting report may be formally correct but not very informative. However, we should not forget that this is Odessa’s first attempt to implement the Strategy. The experience gained and the process of learning from mistakes may also prove useful.
Conclusion
The Action Plan makes the Odessa Development Strategy significantly more concrete. Instead of general goals, the city now has a list of projects, estimated funding needs, responsible implementers, and performance indicators.
At the same time, the Action Plan should not be viewed as a list of 330 tasks that the city simply must complete by the end of 2027. The projects vary greatly in scale, cost, and scope; some depend on securing external funding; and the quality of the indicators does not always allow for an accurate assessment of the actual results of the work done.
Therefore, it will be far more important to look not at the percentage of items formally completed, but at which projects were actually implemented, what resources were mobilized for this purpose, and what changes this has brought about in the city. For Odesa, this is the first time working with a strategy in this format, so an important outcome of this cycle could be gaining an understanding of its own mistakes before preparing the next Strategy for 2028–2034.
This article was prepared by Intent as part of a partnership within the “Circle of Influence” project. The editorial team independently determines the content, focus, and conclusions of this publication.
The initiative is implemented by the NGO “Community Development Fund ‘DOBRO’” in collaboration with the NGO “STEP” as part of the “Circle of Influence” project, with support from NED. Project partners: the NGO “Zmistom,” the Public Association “Odesa Strategy,” the Odesa City Council’s Department of Economic Development, the Odesa City Council’s Department of Labor and Social Policy, the social communications agency “Shchyro,” and the media outlet Intent.
