20 November 2026
(Odessa Regional Clinical Hospital. PHOTO: ratelist.top)
Arista Asset was denied its claim to recover more than 1.06 million hryvnias from the Odesa Regional Clinical Hospital. The company sought compensation for damages caused by flooding of its leased premises during roof repairs.
Thisis stated in the decision of the Odesa Regional Commercial Court dated November 5.
The court case notes that since 2018, Arista Asset LLC has been leasing 198 square meters of space from the hospital on Akademika Zabolotnogo Street. A radiation therapy center for cancer patients operates there.
As noted in the case, in the spring of 2025, the hospital began major repairs on the facade and roof of this building. On the night of May 26–27, 2025, it rained, and the premises leased by the LLC were flooded. It is stated that the ceilings, walls, floors, lighting fixtures, video surveillance and fire alarm systems, and computer equipment were damaged.
According to the tenant, spare parts for the linear accelerator used for treatment were also damaged. Consequently, patient admissions were suspended for a time.
See also:A court in Odesa terminated a 148-million contract for the hospital’s restoration
A commission composed of representatives from both sides drew up a damage report. Two experts concluded that the cause was a violation of the roof repair process.
Subsequently, the tenant repaired the premises at his own expense, spending over one million hryvnias. He demanded that the hospital reimburse him for these costs. In court, the tenant insisted that the client was liable for the contractor’s actions.
The court completely rejected the company’s claims. It pointed to the lack of evidence that the contractor had violated the technical specifications or the procedure for carrying out the repair work, as well as the failure to prove a causal link between the builders’ actions and the flooding.
Read also:A hospital in the Odesa region selected a supplier for an X-ray system worth 15 million without a competitive bidding process
In addition, the court noted the tenant’s own failure to comply with the contractually stipulated procedure for approving repair work, as well as the lack of evidence that all of the plaintiff’s claimed expenses were objectively necessary specifically to remedy the consequences of this incident.
Юлія Калабайда
Nov. 20, 2026
The Gaming Laptop with the Best Value for the Money: What to Look for When Choosing One Advertisement