09 January 2022, 16:40

Lawyers have filed an appeal against the court's decision regarding the rights of the Roma evicted from Loshchynivka

Ця стаття також доступна українською

Lawyers have filed an appeal against the court's decision regarding the rights of the Roma evicted from Loshchynivka

Yulia Lisova and Volodymyr Kondur, representatives of the Roma who were evicted in 2016, filed an appeal against the decision of the Odesa District Administrative Court to completely deny the claim filed on behalf of the evicted individuals. 

As attorney Yulia Lisova told us, they received the new ruling from the Odessa District Administrative Court—which completely denied our claim on behalf of the evicted Roma—on December 6: “In my opinion, this is the most regressive ruling in the entire history of this case’s proceedings in court.” 

The lawyer points out that, according to the law, a person may only be evicted from their place of residence on the basis of a court decision, which does not exist in this case. Furthermore, it is the direct duty of the village head not to bow to the will of the majority, but to act as a guarantor of citizens’ constitutional rights, regardless of their nationality.

Yulia Lisova also briefly summarized the key points of this decision:

  • the eviction of Roma from the village is an expression of direct democracy, to which the village residents are entitled. The village head merely formalized this decision;
  • since the Roma initially fled the village (while their homes were being destroyed), and the eviction order was signed by the head the following day, there is no causal link between the eviction and the decision;
  • there is no need to involve the Main Directorate of the National Police in the Odesa Region in these events, since the Izmail Police Department had the authority to resolve all these issues. And it is normal and reasonable that 10 helpless police officers were deployed against 180 enraged people. After all, it was Saturday evening;
  • Having been in the village since early morning investigating the murder of a girl, the National Police could not have suspected that mass unrest was brewing and only learned of it when they received a phone call reporting the riots at 7:30 p.m. 

As a reminder, on the night of August 27–28, 2016, in the village of Loshchynivka in the Izmail District of the Odesa Region, local residents, outraged by the murder of a young girl,ransacked the homes of Roma. Police officers did nothing to stop the rioters, and village head Viktor Paskalov stated at a community meeting that “members of the Romani community are committing crimes in the village” and therefore “they must be evicted.” Afterward, the head, together with the villagers, drafted the so-called “Resolution No. 1 of the Meeting of Residents of the Village of Loshchynivka,” in which they demanded the deportation of the Roma.

In April 2019, the Fifth Administrative Court of Appealsruled thatthe Loshchynivka Village Council and the Main Directorate of the National Police in Odesa Oblastmust pay compensationfor moral damages to the Roma who suffered as a result of the pogroms in the village. Each plaintiff was to receive 10,000 hryvnias. In addition, the court ruled that the police’s inaction during the pogromswasunlawful andupheld the decision of the courtof first instance, whichhad foundonly the inaction of the village council chairto be unlawful.

The Supreme Court of Ukraine overturned the lower courts’ rulings that the Roma victims of the pogroms in Loshchynivka should be compensated for moral damages andremanded the case for a new trial.

It should be noted that, with the support of the Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union, the victims’ complaints in this case are already pending before the European Court of Human Rights.

The Community Justice Center has been monitoring and studying the progress of this case and has repeatedly cited it as an example of a failed resolution of a community conflict.

Share