22 November 2026, 19:01
A hospital in Kherson lost a 4-million lawsuit against a contractor
Ця стаття також доступна українською
PHOTO: okraska-profi.com.ua
A hospital in Kherson was denied its request to recover more than 3.86 million hryvnias from a contractor, which the medical facility considered an overpayment for repairs to a shelter. The court ruled that the findings of the State Audit Service were insufficient to justify a refund, given that the hospital itself had previously accepted all the work and had no objections.
This is stated in a ruling by the Commercial Court of Poltava Oblast.
The court also denied the hospital’s request to order construction-technical and economic expert assessments. Furthermore, the court did not involve the Kherson City Military Administration in the case, as the medical facility is an independent legal entity.
The ruling states that in March 2024, the Municipal Non-Profit Enterprise “O.S. Luchansky Kherson City Clinical Hospital” entered into a contract with the company “Alsvyt Plus.” The contractor was to carry out the renovation of a storage facility with a medical operating unit.
The court case files indicate that during construction, the parties adjusted the deadlines and the total cost of the contract several times through supplementary agreements. At the same time, the hospital accepted the completed work based on completion certificates and paid for it in full.
Read also:Contractor Wins 5 Million in Lawsuit Against Kherson Regional State Administration
It is noted that after the renovation was completed, the State Audit Service conducted an audit. The auditors stated that part of the construction work was not substantiated by the control survey, and the contractor’s expenses for materials and travel were found to be overstated.
Based on this audit report and its own measurements, the hospital filed a lawsuit to recover the allegedly overpaid funds.
The court sided with the contractor and emphasized that the client must verify the scope and cost of the work at the time of acceptance. If the reports are signed without any comments, the client effectively agrees to their quality and price and cannot later demand a refund by revising what has already been accepted.
Read also:In Kherson, a suspect accused of causing millions in losses at a school shelter was released on bail
