20 November 2026, 16:59
A court denied a community in the Odesa region's request to collect one million from a contractor
Ця стаття також доступна українською
"Romashka" Preschool. PHOTO: fontanska-rada.gov.ua
The Ovidopol Town Council in the Odesa region was denied its request to recover more than 1.58 million hryvnias from the private company "Ukrspetsstroy." The community had sought to recover funds that, according to the State Audit Service’s findings, it had overpaid to the contractor during the renovation of the local “Romashka” kindergarten.
This is stated in a decision by the Commercial Court of Odesa Oblast dated November 11.
The Ovidopol Town Council was also ordered to pay 19,000 hryvnias in court costs.
The dispute concerned two construction contracts signed in 2018 and 2020. The town council paid the company over 30 million hryvnias for the construction work performed and signed all acceptance certificates without any objections.
See also:A department of the Odesa City Council was unable to recover VAT from a contractor
Subsequently, the Southern Office of the State Audit Service conducted an audit and found that the scope and cost of the repairs had been overstated by 1,584,250 hryvnias. Based on this report, the town council filed a lawsuit demanding that “Ukrspetsstroy” be held liable for the losses incurred by the budget.
The court rejected the community’s claims, noting that the auditors’ audit report does not in itself alter the terms of the contract and does not constitute an unconditional basis for recovering funds. The court noted that the client had not provided any other evidence to substantiate actual losses. The court also pointed out that the town council had previously accepted the work without any complaints, which deprived it of the right to cite obvious defects at a later date.
The court also took into account that the contractor had submitted a forensic expert’s report confirming that the scope and cost of the work fully complied with the project documentation.
