22 November 2026

A human resources inspector in the Mykolaiv region successfully challenged a fine imposed by the Tax and Customs Service in court

(PHOTO: sud.ua)

The South Ukrainian City Court in Mykolaiv Oblast overturned a ruling imposing a fine of 34,000 hryvnias on a human resources inspector at a local company for an alleged violation of military registration rules.

In late August 2026, a joint commission comprising representatives of the territorial recruitment center and the executive committee of the South Ukrainian City Council inspected how military registration was being conducted at the “Kvant” enterprise and fined the HR inspector, according to Mykolaiv News.

The Territorial Recruitment Center stated that the company had failed to verify military registration documents during the hiring process, had not compiled the necessary files and lists (particularly regarding women on military registration), and had not sent a registered letter to an employee on leave.

The HR inspector herself disagreed with the allegations and claimed that the charges of military registration violations were made without evidence—in particular, she provided a certificate stating that there had never been any medical personnel on the company’s staff. However, the key issue was a procedural error on the part of the Military Registration and Enlistment Office itself.

By law, after drawing up the report, the head of the Military Registration and Enlistment Office must review the administrative case at the office and decide whether to issue a fine. The individual must be notified in writing in advance of the date, time, and place of this hearing so that they can attend, provide their explanation, or request a lawyer. However, the report specified only the year and time of the hearing at the Military Registration and Enlistment Office—2:00 p.m.—while the specific date and month were left blank. As a result, the decision to impose the fine was issued without the employee’s participation.

The TCC claimed that the woman had allegedly been notified of the date verbally and cited their employees’ reports as evidence, but the court found this to be insufficient proof.

The court emphasized that if a person is not properly notified of the time and place of an administrative hearing, they are deprived of their right to a defense. This constitutes a gross violation of procedure.

Кирило Бойко

You may also like:

Nov. 22, 2026

A hospital in Kherson lost a 4-million lawsuit against a contractor

A teenager from the Odesa region was sentenced to one year of probation for attempting to smuggle people across the border

The Odessa Employment Center won a lawsuit against an individual entrepreneur for a grant

In Fontanka, Odesa Oblast, the dismantling of the disputed property has been banned

A court in the Odesa region denied a request to seize 6.5 million in assets from a developer